At a recent library presentation I showed attendees my very messy notebook page (8.5×11 inches) scribbled with the beginnings of a new novel plot. The entire novel was on that messy page.
I had scrawled a line across the 11 inches and added marks to represent the must-haves in structure: three acts and Midpoint Crisis. White space on that notebook page contained scribbles of characters and names, relationships to the suspect, a possible motive, places for bad deeds, and notes about possible serious actions.
That messiness is familiar to most writers.
Now transfer “being messy” to your key characters. Characters who get themselves into a mess and then get out of it are the stuff of great stories.
As soon as we see a messy situation on a page or in a movie, we’re hooked. How will the character get out of the MESS?
Messiness gets you out of a rut with a dull character or plot or chapter.
Messes lure us. Messes mean multiple issues or problems happen at once or are compounded.
It takes work to create character and plot messiness and resolve messes, but we live messy lives and we love witnessing how characters get out of messes.
The best writers in all genres create a character in the middle of a mess of some sort from the start and add to it certainly at the Midpoint Crisis and Climax.
A story might start without a mess, but readers seem to want to see a mess unfold within only a few paragraphs or pages. Give us a mess as the hook, then even more of a mess for your cliffhanger.
Here’s an example of revising for messiness:
Consider the classic scene: A driver with an urgent need to get to a hospital to see a buddy has to suddenly stop for cows or sheep crossing a road. You could have your character wait (maybe even impatiently) and your character gets around the sheep and zooms onward to the hospital to visit their friend.
Boring. Seen it before.
What if you revised for messiness? Give readers more entertainment that will sell your book or script.
A mess is more than just pausing for sheep. Messiness is created by a series of problems and decisions that often go wrong quickly.
As an example of a revision, the scene is now a sequence of scenes: Your character stops for the sheep, but this time is more impatient so your character decides to turn around and take a different road, BUT that delivers him to an encampment with people who steal his car and take his shoes and phone. THEN, he decides to walk a certain direction and that’s a mistake and he becomes filthy, and then he hitches a ride with a minister who is late for a funeral so NOW your character has to ride along before getting shoes from the church donation box and FINALLY your character in a hurry begs for a ride in the now-empty hearse and gets an interesting driver in the bargain to give him a ride to the hospital.
Messiness gives us a glimpse of how DETERMINED your character and YOU can be.
Messiness is usually more ENTERTAINING and SELLABLE than the opposite of it.

